Chef Notes: Holy Meatballs

Chef Notes: Holy Meatballs

There are few foods more perfect, more enticing, more versatile than meatballs. While a little messy (no one likes forming the balls, they get your hands slimy) they’re easy to make and perfect for making large batches and freezing for later. The serving ideas are almost endless. They make great appetizers with no sauce or in a marinara, creamy mushroom gravy, or barbecue sauce served with toothpicks. You can use them in soups or on top of warm/wilted salads. They’re awesome served in sandwich rolls with melted cheese and marinara sauce for a game day treat. You can’t beat traditional spaghetti and meatballs. Try crumbling them up on homemade pizza. Or do a gorgeous retro dish like Swedish meatballs. 

Here’s my recipe, adapted from Mario Batali’s. I change this up from time-to-time by switching up the herbs and spices, leaving out the dried fruit altogether, or switching up the raisins for some other dried fruit, which believe it or not does add something to the balls. The recipe doubles well and you can substitute turkey for the veal or pork but I encourage you to use at least two different meats as your balls will have a better texture and a richer flavor. You can also use the fat free evaporated milk if you prefer and regular raisins or even other dried fruits like figs, apricots, prunes, and pineapple work well too.

Chef Notes: Holy Meatballs


  • Olive oil (not EVOO just regular)
  • 1 large onion, finely diced
  • 3 large cloves garlic, finely diced
  • ½ cup golden raisins, finely chopped
  • 3 T basil, fine chiffonade
  • 3 large eggs
  • 1 can evaporated milk
  • 1 whole nutmeg, finely grated (optional)
  • 1 lb ground pork
  • 1 lb ground beef
  • 1 lb ground veal
  • Seasoned panko breadcrumbs
  • Kosher salt to taste
  • Freshly ground black pepper to taste


Heat oven to 375.  

In a sauté pan, caramelize the onions, garlic, and raisins over med-low heat. 

Remove from heat, stir in the basil and season to taste with salt and pepper. 

Let cool slightly and add to a blender with the eggs, milk, and nutmeg to taste (I use all of it but not everyone is as crazy about nutmeg as I). 

Blend until fairly smooth.

Pour into a large mixing bowl with the meats.

Sprinkle generously with breadcrumbs, remember you can always add more but I don’t know of any way to remove them. 

Season well with salt and pepper. 

Using your hands, mix until incorporated.  Don’t over mix.  Over mixing can make your meatballs too dense. 

The mixture should be fairly wet so that when you form your test ball it holds together, but just barely.  Add more breadcrumbs if necessary. 

Quickly sauté one or two golf ball sized balls in a bit of olive oil and taste to ensure proper seasoning.  Adjust if necessary.

Hand form the rest of your balls, placing them in lightly oiled sheet pans with an inch or so between them, you want them to bake, not steam. 

Bake for 25-30 minutes. 

Test for doneness by cutting one open.  They should be cooked through, with no pink in the middle. 

If you are adding them to a soup or sauce you can gently stir them in immediately, provided that the soup/sauce is fully prepared. 

You don’t want to overcook the meatballs by having them simmer in your sauce or soup for any significant amount of time

10-15 minutes is more than adequate to incorporate the flavours. 

Or you can cool the balls for a few minutes and refrigerate for about one week or store in the freezer for 2-3 months.


You might also like


A Quick Bite with Virginia Johnson

There’s a cotton dress of Virginia Johnson’s that’s covered in sea blue whales. I bought it a week before my first child was born when I really was as big as a beluga. It’s


Soup Roundup

Laura and I always joke that we could actually start a pancake blog. We’ve created so many posts celebrating the many, many variations that are possible with our beloved breakfast

By Meal Type

We Resolve to…Eat Better Snacks

I have an obsession. It’s the oat bar at Starbucks. (Dear Oat Bar, I love you with my latte and hate it when Scarlett makes me share you!) I haven’t gotten the


  1. jan Clements
    December 13, 11:23 Reply

    They also make great after-school snacks and are much healthier than sweets. The kids love them on rolls or English muffins. The protein holds them well until dinner and does not raise blood sugar as do sweet snacks. Love the substitution suggestions.

  2. Michelle
    December 15, 22:57 Reply

    What if you wanted to remove the evaporated milk altogether? If I were to make these kosher-style, can I just leave out the milk?

Leave a Reply